« links for 2006-04-01 | Main | Manifesto from the Blogosphere »

The difference between Employee and Corporate blogs

The Wall Street Journal today published a story on employee/corporate blogging (apparently, they do not understand the semantical difference). The article is called "The Inside View," and I would link to it, but I can't seem to find the proper URL.

The article itself is the pretty standard, blogs give a human voice but also a scary loss of control, piece that we have read dozens of times over the past year.

Pro employee blogs: "Enthusiasts say such blogs by company employees -- sanctioned, if not sponsored, by the companies themselves -- put a human face on a corporation and provide a way to reach customers and counter critics."

Anti-employee blogs: "But the growing trend worries many corporate image specialists, who foresee a confusing array of corporate messages, some of which are so sanitized they lack credibility. Lawyers fear worse: that some employees' thoughts may provide fodder for plaintiffs' lawyers or give away company secrets or advice that a company prefers to sell."

I think the important thing this blog points to is growing confusion and lumping together of employee and corporate blogs. I would like to give my definition of a corporate versus employee blog.

corporate blog: A blog written as part of one's job, hosted by the company and serving as a representative voice of the organization (examples: Bob Lutz's FastLane blog for GM, Richard Edelman's 6 A.M. blog for Edelman [my company])

employee blog: A blog written by an employee of an organization that may or may not address work-related issues, is not hosted by the organization and is not viewed by the company as an official representataive. (example: millions of random personal blogs)

Then, there are those fuzzy situations like Robert Scoble at Microsoft or Steve Rubel (now my colleague at Edelman) whose employee blogs have grown in stature to the point where they are seen as voices for their respective companies

This is one of those square-rectangle situations. Just as a square is a rectangle, but a rectangle is not neccessarily a square; so to is a corporate blog an employee blog, but an employee blog is not neccessarily a corporate blog.

HOWEVER, while this distinction is important from a standpoint of liability and regulatory ability, consumers and journalist are not likley to confine themselves to "official" corporate blogs. In fact, blogs written by middle-management or customer-facing employees are likely to be seen as more credible than those of senior executives.

This makes developing a employee blogging policy, AND communicating that policy all the more important.

Corporate communicators are now dividing themsleves into three camps:
1. Those who see blogs as a potential vehicle to build relationships with and leverage the collective power of internal and external communities
2. Those who see blogs as a loss of control and a inevitable legal, public relations and financial disaster
3. Those who ignore and dismiss blogs as a passing fad

Conclusion:
Those in camp three are totally missing the point, becuase blogs are here now so you better deal with them. As for camps one and two, I am sure you know where I fall, but that is not relevant. Regardless of whether you think blogs are a salvation or the devil, the way you deal with them ought to be similar. You need to monitor what is being said and you need to have strategic process in place to effectively communicate your story.


Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c9e5c53ef00e5506d2eb28833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The difference between Employee and Corporate blogs:

» Blogs toll? Blogs böse? Egal. from Das E-Business Weblog
Ein hübsches Zitat, das ich heute bei Jeffrey Treem aufgeschnappt habe: Regardless of whether you think blogs are a salvation or the devil, the way you deal with them ought... [Read More]

» Weblogs Heil oder Verderben? from ThoBlog
Sind Weblogs Heil oder Verderben? via MartinRegardless of whether you think blogs are a salvation or the... [Read More]

Comments

I have nothing to add to this piece, which is significant given that I ALWAYS have something to say.

So thank you for a well-written complete piece.

Dominic,

Thanks for the kind words. Next time I will write something vague and circumscript so that I can get your input ;-)

-Jeffrey

There may be one other style that's missing. the Professional blog.

The Professional blog is a blog that is focused on an individual's career, and is specifically about this individuals craft and passion, with little 'personal' information, but does not represent a company.

That is where my blog falls (linked from my name above) and is completely different to my personal blog that is run separately.

Jeremiah,

Man I love semantics.

You are exactly right, however, I would imagine most blogs that are focused on an individual's career are what I would call employee blogs. Yes, they certainly are higher brow than most myspace blogs, but that is matter of opinion.

Remember, it doesn't matter if you talk about where you work or not, you are still liable for what you write.

And I would like to think that most most bloggers are employeed (at least for now).

If you also have a personal blog that just makes you an employee blogger twice over.

I've grappeled with this very concept for some time, it gets gray in these here parts. I've put some thoughts on my own blog, and would love to get your feedback.

We both agree on your points and conclusions around the three divisions of corporate communciators --solid thinking.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

My Photo

Disclaimer

  • This blog is the sole responsibility of ME. Any content contained within represent my personal opinions and actions and not those of my employer or anyone who purports to exert influence on me. I pay for this blog and I spend my personal time supporting it. If you have any comments, suggestions, criticisms, praise, ridicule or good jokes, send them my way.

FYI: My Former Life

  • All posts prior to September 2007 were created while I was employed by Edelman as a Change and Employee Engagement Analyst

Technorati